Download Israel in History: The Jewish State in Comparative by Derek Penslar PDF

By Derek Penslar

Masking topical matters about the nature of the Israeli kingdom, this attractive paintings provides essays that mix various comparative schemes, either inner to Jewish civilization and lengthening in the course of the international, resembling: glossy Jewish society, politics and tradition old realization within the 20th century colonialism, anti-colonialism and postcolonial state-building. With its open-ended, comparative process, Israel in historical past offers an invaluable technique of correcting the biases present in a lot scholarship on Israel, be it sympathetic or adverse. This e-book will entice students and scholars with study pursuits in lots of fields, together with Israeli reports, heart East experiences, and Jewish reports.

Show description

Read Online or Download Israel in History: The Jewish State in Comparative Perspective PDF

Best israel & palestine books

Nationalism and the Israeli State: Bureaucratic Logic In Public Events

What are the origins of Israeli nationalism? what's the cultural common sense in the back of nationwide gala's, army parades and patriotic memorials? How does a rustic like Israel rework state-related public occasions into enactments of nationalism? during this e-book, Don Handelman considers the that means of Holocaust and armed forces memorialism in Israel.

Israelism: Arab Scholarship on Israel, a Critical Assessment

For many years, ideological discourses have ruled the Arab global. necessarily this has had a profound effect at the approach of many Arab students. during this booklet, Hassan A. Barari significantly assesses the prestige of Israeli stories within the Arab international. students' incompetence and their loss of major region reviews abilities have contributed to the underdevelopment of Israeli reports in such a lot Arab counties.

Rethinking contemporary warfare: a sociological view of the Al-Aqsa Intifada

Examines the wrestle adventure of Israel's flooring forces within the Al-Aqsa Intifada for you to supply a suite of leading edge recommendations for figuring out abnormal conflict.

Settling for Less: The Planned Resettlement of Israel's Negev Bedouin

"This is a superb learn of an immense and well timed subject that's of relevance not just for the folk concerned yet for the broader components of Israel and the Arab global. it's a entire distinct description and research of a technique of swap and transformation that began in 1948 and maintains until eventually the current.

Extra info for Israel in History: The Jewish State in Comparative Perspective

Sample text

24 Sternhell was right that Labor Zionist political culture was imbued with militarism, but one can encounter this argument in a wide variety of scholarship written from varying disciplinary and political perspectives. The 1980s witnessed the formation of a school of Israeli sociology known as critical sociology, which can be seen as adumbrating and then running parallel with the ‘‘new history’’ that came to the fore at the end of the decade. Thanks largely to the influence of the late Yonathan Shapiro, who pioneered 36 Writing Israeli history the field of Israeli historical sociology and trained many students, a number of important studies in the field began to appear from the mid-1980s onward.

But the adversarial ethos which informs the new Israeli historiography can affect its arguments in negative ways as well. American Cold War Revisionists have been criticized for offering too schematic a 22 Writing Israeli history presentation, which conceals the uncertainty and improvisation of policy formulated under extreme conditions. 35 Moreover, the new historians’ desire to compensate for the errors of official Israeli military historiography can skew their presentation. 36 Pappe´’s The Making of the Arab–Israeli Conflict offers an apparently impartial (if questionable) distinction between the 1948 War’s military history, which he describes as ‘‘microhistorical’’ and hence unimportant, and its political-diplomatic history, which is ‘‘macrohistorical’’ and thus the center of the author’s attention.

The limitation of the study of Israeli history to Israel itself is also the product of the collective psychology of Jewish studies scholars and the programs in which they teach. In the field of Jewish studies, as it has flourished in North America over the past three decades, historical study has focused primarily on issues of immediate concern to Jews in their lands of residence: antisemitism and the Holocaust, assimilation and ethnicity, religiosity and cultural expression. Although Zionism can be of considerable interest to historians as a mobilizing force and a source of Jewish identity in a particular time and place (for example interwar Poland, the United States during the 1970s), Jewish historians outside of Israel tend to look upon international Zionist politics, the development of the Yishuv, and the history of the Israeli state as something distant, even foreign.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.70 of 5 – based on 48 votes